APPLYING THE STRENGTH REDUCTION
METHOD TO STUDY OF STABILITY OF
RESIDUAL MOUNTAINS: A PARTICULAR
APPLICATION
Xin Jin*
College of Art and Design, Shaanxi University of Science and Technology, Xi’an,
Shaanxi, 710021, China
wyjinxin@sust.edu.cn
Yucheng Hua
College of Art and Design, Shaanxi University of Science and Technology, Xi’an,
Shaanxi, 710021, China
Qiao Tang
College of Art and Design, Shaanxi University of Science and Technology, Xi’an,
Shaanxi, 710021, China
Reception: 31/11/2022 Acceptance: 26/11/2022 Publication: 21/01/2023
Suggested citation:
J., Xin, H., Yucheng and T., Qiao. (2023). Applying the strength reduction
method to study of stability of residual mountains: A particular
application. 3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicada a la pyme, 12(1),
33-52. https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
33
ABSTRACT
Due to huge disaster-caused force, seismic geological disasters primarily induce
residual landslide, collapse and debris flow disasters with far higher hazard extent
than that of earthquake disasters. Wherefore, this paper, with various vibration slopes
caused by the most representative Wenchuan earthquake as research objects,
introduces the strength reduction method to the stability study of residual mountains in
a certain area, puts forward dynamic stability slope evaluation method based on
dynamic and overall strength reduction method to obtain the mountain slope stability
situation in the process of gradual instability, searches out the sliding surface of
progressive expansion making use of dynamic strength reduction method and
calculates dynamic safety index in the process of gradual slope instability pursuant to
the calculation advantages of dynamic strength reduction method, so as to realize the
analysis and regulation of the whole process of slope instability. The results show that
in the stability analysis of a homogeneous slope, the safety index of slope stability
calculated by strength reduction method is 6.7%, 8.8% and 10.5% higher than that
calculated by finite element limit equilibrium method, Bishop method and Janbu
method respectively. In the stability analysis of a multi-layer soil slope, the safety
index of slope stability calculated by strength reduction method is 4.8%, 4.3% and
9.4% higher than that calculated by other three algorithms. While in the stability
analysis of soft interlining slope, the safety indexes of slope stability calculated by the
method proposed in this paper are increased by 26.10%, 29.11% and 26.46%
respectively compared with other three algorithms, indicating that the stability of
landslide residual mountains calculated by strength reduction method proposed in this
paper is the highest.
KEYWORDS
Strength reduction method; Landslide residual mountain; Stability study; Safety index;
Sliding surface
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
34
PAPER INDEX
ABSTRACT
KEYWORDS
1. INTRODUCTION
2. FAILURE CHARACTERISTICS OF MOUNTAIN SLOPES AND IMPROVEMENT
OF STRENGTH REDUCTION METHOD
2.1. Deformation and failure characteristics of residual slope after landslide
2.2. Actual failure process of mountain slope
2.3. Sliding surface search based on dynamic strength reduction
3. DYNAMIC STABILITY ANALYSIS OF MOUNTAIN SLOPE BASED ON
STRENGTH REDUCTION METHOD
4. RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
4.1. Landslide residual mountain conditions in a certain area
4.2. Experiment parameters of mountain slope in a certain area
4.3. Compare with the results of different algorithms
5. DISCUSSION
6. CONCLUSION
7. DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT
REFERENCES
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
35
1. INTRODUCTION
In mountainous and hilly areas, landslides are more common, and similar to
earthquakes, mudslides and other disasters, generally have relatively large hazard
extent. In the vast land area of China, the geographical conditions are relatively
complex, and the landslide areas are widely distributed, especially in the mountainous
areas of southwest, northwest, and east China [1-2]. When a landslide occurs, partial
or whole pieces of land will appear one after another in a relatively slow speed and a
relatively long cycle, and will intermittently slide. [3-4].
Landslides are extremely harmful, especially that large-scale landslides can
destroy entire villages, cut off rivers, destroy farmland and forests, and even damage
the safety of life and property of people and countries to a large extent, seriously
hindering and destroying the construction process of countries [5]. Landslides in
China have the characteristics of various types, large scale, wide distribution, strong
concealment and strong destructiveness, and most landslides are sudden and
unpredictable, which brings serious harms to the society [6].
In this regard, it is of great significance to implement monitoring and early warning
of landslides. Landslide movement is highly complex and is affected by many factors.
At present, it is difficult to thoroughly understand the internal characteristics of each
landslide, and to accurately predict each landslide [7-9]. However, landslide
monitoring helps to master and analyze the evolution and characteristics of landslide
mass. With the continuous progress of landslide monitoring technology, in order to
obtain more detailed landslide data, a more in-depth understanding of landslides can
be obtained [10-12].
In recent years, many foreign researchers have carried out research on rock
mechanics algorithms. For example, the literature [13] introduced the concept of
damage mechanics in the metal creep fracture research and rock mechanics research
for the first time. The literature [14] used the concept of fracture surface to
theoretically discuss the continuous damage behavior of rock and concrete. Since
then, people have established various damage theories based on different damage
mechanisms and basic theories, and applied them to the study of nonlinear, plastic,
and viscoplastic damage of rock materials. The literature [15] first applied the damage
theory to establish damage mechanics model of rock-concrete continuum. The
literature [16] established corresponding models and theories based on the structural
characteristics of the rock itself. The literature [17] proposed the famous "strain
equivalence hypothesis", which laid the foundation for the study of damage theory.
The literature [18] proposed a new elastic-plastic damage model based on irreversible
thermodynamics and damage mechanics, which comprehensively considered plastic
friction deformation and plastic pore deformation, and adopted damage variables to
describe the development of microscopic defects. The literature[19] defined a damage
variable as the second-order tensor of fracture density, took into account the damage
evolution of this damage variable pursuant to fracture propagation, and thereby
established a corresponding damage model. Based on the homogenization theory,
whereafter, a thermodynamic framework for the meso-mechanical damage model was
built. Zhu Qizhi et al. reckoned that the rock was a heterogeneous material composed
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
36
of an elastic solid matrix and fractures, and proposed a corresponding meso-
mechanical damage model. The literature [20], on the basis of considering the
dynamic propagation of micro-fractures, proposed a corresponding meso-mechanical
model of rock damages, believing that the stress-strain curve, failure strength and
damage development rate of rocks were closely related to the friction index, initial
fracture length and loading rate. The literature [21] came up with a micro-fracture
damage model of brittle rock under uniaxial compression load as well as theories of
micro-fracture fracture mechanics and rock damage mechanics based on the
assumption of random distribution of micro-fractures. To be concrete, the mechanical
properties under the load were analyzed, that is, when the external load reached a
certain level, the micro-fractures began to expand,, the mechanical properties of the
rock changed, and until the macro-fracture of the rock occurred, the fracture growth
rate increased with the external load.
With the in-depth research aiming at foreign researchers, domestic scholars have
also carried out research on the stability of rock and soil slopes. For instance, based
on the principle of object balance, the literature [22] proposed a finite sliding
displacement evaluation method of slope stability according to slope potential
deformation, in which the force exceeding the yield resistance of the sliding body is
used as the calculation standard for the occurrence of the slope and landslide. The
literature [23] used the FLAC valuation method of slope stability according to slope
potential deformation, and carried out the research of seismic slope failure
mechanism combined with the seismic slope numerical simulation software with both
tensile and shear failure functions. Through analysis, it was concluded that the failure
of the seismic slope was composed of the upper tensile failure and the lower shear
failure of the potential rupture zone, and the method for determining the location of the
rupture surface of the earthquake slope was given through various means. The
literature [24] performed a large number of on-site investigations. Precisely, on the
basis of aforementioned above, the special instability phenomena such as vibration
collapse and high-speed ejection of the slope under the strong earthquake load were
studied, and the genesis mechanism of earthquake-triggered collapse and landslide
was classified according to the specific slope structure. Moreover, a calculation
program for the safety index of a landslide numerical simulation software with both
tensile was proposed to study the stability of slopes under the condition of known
sliding surfaces, and a comparative discussion between the traditional seismic slopes
was carried out via FLAC 3D displacement evaluation method. From a mesoscopic
approach, the literature [26] studied the instability mode of slopes via a strength
reduction calculation module in the RFPA software. The literature [27] discussed the
strength reduction method and proposed a more reasonable reduction calculation
method, which promoted actual use numerical simulation software with both tensile.
With the deepening of research, there are more and more improved algorithms for
strength reduction. However, numerous studies have found that in order to study the
stability of residual mountains, it urgently requires to take into account the shear-
tensile composite yield criterion of mountains, as well as single static safety index,
principal stress and cohesion of mountain slopes. For this, numerical simulation
software with both tensile did calculate damaged area of the mountain slope [28-30],
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
37
but did not consider the soil layer of the mountain slope. Not all the soil layers of the
mountains are homogeneous, and some soil layers are multi-layer soil or contain
weak inter-layers, so it is very necessary to study the stability of the residual mountain
according to the conditions of different soil layers.
Pursuant to the fact that the general algorithm does not take into account the pull
fracture and further study landslide residual mountains, in this paper, the shape
change and structural damage characteristics of the residual slopes on the rear wall of
the landslide is analyzed, and the sliding surface searching of progressive expansion
is implemented making use of dynamic strength reduction method. At the same time,
the residual slope of the rear wall of a landslide in a certain area is also a typical
representative and epitome of the many shaking slopes of the "5.12" Wenchuan
earthquake. It can be predicted that in the next 3 to 5 years, it will be a period of high
incidence of collapse, landslides and debris flows in earthquake-stricken areas. The
research ideas, methods and understanding of its post-earthquake stability will also
provide guidance and reference for the evaluation of similar slopes in earthquake-
stricken areas.
2. FAILURE CHARACTERISTICS OF MOUNTAIN
SLOPES AND IMPROVEMENT OF STRENGTH
REDUCTION METHOD
2.1. DEFORMATION AND FAILURE CHARACTERISTICS OF
RESIDUAL SLOPE AFTER LANDSLIDE
According to the interpretation of low-altitude aerial photography near the residual
mountain on the rear wall of a landslide in a certain area by helicopter, and combined
with on-site geological mapping, it shows that after the "5.12" earthquake, there are
mainly three groups of fractures on the surface of the entire back-edge mountains[31].
And the distribution of residual mountains and fractures on the rear wall of the
landslide is primarily: (1) N40°50°E and N70°E
EW direction, this group of
fractures is mainly consistent with the boundary of the rear wall of a landslide in a
certain area, with an extension length of about 20200m and; (2) N10°W ~ near SN
direction ~ N10°E, this group of fractures is the same as the main direction of the
Dashuigou and Xiaoshuigou valleys, with an extension length of about 50 ~ 400m,
and showing that unloading and tension are towards the free surface of the big and
small ditches, but the scale of the side of the small ditch is obviously small; (3) N70°W
direction, this group of fractures are distributed on the ridge line of the highest
watershed and are consistent with the trend of the ridge line, with an extension length
of about about 1000m and belonging to the earthquake-vibration fractures on the
steep slope of the ridge [32].
The above-mentioned fractures are all extensional, with an opening width of 10-50
cm. Since the penetration depth of each fracture cannot be measured, according to
the earthquake in the core area (such as Dujiangyan, Yingxiu, Wolong, Beichuan,
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
38
Qingchuan, etc.), the characteristics of the slope seismic effect (that is, the slope
slump effect caused by the earthquake on the thin ridge with a slope gradient of
obviously more than 50° and without deep tensile fracture) are adopted to predict the
distribution of the residual mountain mass on the rear wall of the landslide in a certain
area. The depth of the pull fracture is generally between 10 and 50m. Except for the
N40°-50° E group fractures near the front edge of the mountain, which has penetrated
into the weakly weathered rock body, the rest of the fractures near the ridge line are
expected to be a deep location within the strongly weathered rock body. [33].
Judging from the distribution of the above-mentioned three groups of fractures with
different extension directions and scales, the shallow surface layer of the entire
residual mountain has basically been disturbed as a whole. Instead, collapse, slide
and pull fractures also occur in the direction of large and small ditches, but the former
has more advantages. Although the superficial integrity of the residual mountain has
been basically completely destroyed, the integrity of the underlying weakly weathered
rock mass has remained basically intact.
2.2. ACTUAL FAILURE PROCESS OF MOUNTAIN SLOPE
The slope instability is a gradual process that evolves from part to the whole, rather
than an instant process. Because of existence of weak surface, the mechanical index
of mountain slope decreases due to rainfall, the load dustribution is unbalanced and
local stress concentration occurs, thereby resulting in some elements are damaged
first [34]. Slowly, the principal stress will continue to extend and adjust its own
concentration after the internal components is damaged, regrouping into a stress
region. At this time, the damage area of the mountain structure increases and
converges, and finally becomes a complete mass through sliding surface. Figure 1
shows the whole process of slope damage.
Figure 1. Schematic diagram of progressive failure of mountain slope
In Figure 1, at points 1 and 2, if the shear force is greater than that of the peak
point, the mechanical index will decrease due to rainfall,. At this time, it can be
Potential sliding
surface
Sliding
belt
1
2
3
3
1
2
4
o
τ
γ
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
39
regarded as that the shear stress at point 3 has just peaked, and the shear stress at
point 4 is well below the peak value. Moreover, since the sliding belt will continue to
expand, the stress will be completed at point 4, the highest point will be completed at
point 4, and at the same time, a complete sliding surface will be formed. Obviously,
when the sliding zone is produced, its strength value will change from the highest
point to the lowest point. In this way, the whole process can improve the
characteristics of the formation of the Osian sliding zone.
The damage of slope structure and the process of landslide are not sudden, but
gradual. Also, the slope instability is a gradual unsuccessful process, so it is
necessary to reflect the whole gradual process of slope stability for evaluation [35]. If
the strength value of the slope instability is wanted to decrease, strength reduction
calculation will cause the final plastic zone to be too large.
2.3. SLIDING SURFACE SEARCH BASED ON DYNAMIC
STRENGTH REDUCTION
The whole process deformation characteristics of geotechnical materials are mainly
classified into two types, namely "hardening" and "softening". Regarding the shape
change and mechanism damage characteristics of the sliding belt in the unsafe
process of mountain slope, relevant researchers have verified via theory and
experiments that the sliding belt of the slope has softening characteristics. Thus, the
slope stability analysis must take into account the strain softening characteristics of
geotechnical materials [36].
Based on referred strength reduction criteria and softening characteristics of the
sliding belt, some scholars first proposed a calculation method and then obtained the
parameters for reducing the local slope strength cohesion and internal friction angle,
as shown in Figure 2
Figure 2. Strength reduction calculation process
Figure 2 shows the strength reduction process in detail, in which the minimum
value of principal stress calculated is the same as the value of tensile failure strength.
Concretely, it is first to destroy the reduction element index, and then obtain the
Elastoplastic Mechanics
Calculations
Determining the Slope
Plastic Region
Rreduction factor
K
Reduced local slope strength
parameters
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
40
parameters for reducing the local slope strength cohesion and internal friction angle,
so as to perform mechanical calculation aiming at the slope plastic region. Assuming
that the deformation strength characteristics of the sliding zone geotechnical materials
conform to the ideal elastic-plastic softening model, by calculating the damaged area
of the mountain slope according to the elastic-plastic criterion, it is found that the area
of slope increases slowly, which stops when the slope state reaches the limit
equilibrium [37].
Tensile failure often occurs in a certain range of landslide crest, so after
determining mechanical strength parameters of the sliding belt shear yielding, it is
very necessary to integrate the Mohr Coulomb tensile failure model into the numerical
study, that is, if the minimum value of principal stress is the same as the value of
tensile failure strength, the rock and soil mass will suffer unsafe state process. Tensile
composite yield criterion can be expressed as:
1
A single static safety index can be expressed as:
(2)
In the above formulas, and
are the maximum and minimum principal
stresses, respectively; is the cohesion force; is the internal friction angle; and
is the tensile strength.
The tensile strength of the slope is basically unchanged, so the tensile strength is
not reduced in the strength reduction method [38-39]. Only under the conditions that
earthquake and other basic factors work, the tensile strength of the slope will be and
needs to be reduced. When calculating the damaged area of the slope according to
the elastic-plastic criterion, the mechanical strength parameter of the sliding belt is
narrowed by the reduction factor , that is:
3
In the above formula, and are the cohesion force and the internal friction
angle of the local damaged area, respectively
3. DYNAMIC STABILITY ANALYSIS OF MOUNTAIN
SLOPE BASED ON STRENGTH REDUCTION
METHOD
From the above data research and actual operation, it is obvious that whether the
slope is safe and stable as time goes by, the whole process of the slope from local
3
0
t
t
Fσ σ==
1 3
1 sin 2 cos 0
1 sin 1 sin
s
c
Fσ σ
+ϕ ϕ
=+ =
ϕ ϕ
1
σ
3
σ
c
ϕ
t
σ
K
tan
arctan
loc
loc
c
c
K
K
=
ϕ
ϕ=
loc
c
loc
ϕ
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
41
failure and gradual development to overall instability will change dynamically,
experiencing stable, less stable and unstable evolutionary processes.
The steps for evaluating the dynamic stability of mountain slopes are shown in
Figure 3.
Figure 3. Dynamic evaluation process of mountain slope stability
In the traditional slope stability evaluation method, a single static safety index
is
used to evaluate the slope stability, but the static safety index
is not conducive to
the stability analysis and regulation of landslide disasters. Therefore, this paper
proposes that the safety index is a dynamic stability evaluation index.
(1) When the plastic zone appears in the local element of the mountain slope, the
mechanical parameters of the element in the plastic zone are reduced to indicate that
the strength of the local element softens and decreases.
(2) The overall strength reduction method and formula (4) are adopted to reduce
the strength parameters and
, of the entire slope. The reduction range includes
not only the softened plastic zone, but also the unyielding slope. For the plastic zone
in step (1), the softened parameter value is reduced. When the reduction reaches a
sudden change in the slope displacement, the safety index
in the current state is
obtained.
(3) According to Figure 3, after the strength parameters and
are reduced, the
elastoplastic mechanical balance calculation is carried out. Since the elements around
the plastic zone of stress concentration will generate a new plastic zone, the plastic
zone elements will increase.
(4) The increase of plastic zone elements indicates the expansion of the slope
sliding surface. At this time, the mechanical parameters of the newly formed sliding
surface are reduced according to steps (1) and (3).
Edge model Initial and Boundary Conditions Reduction factor
Safety factor calculation
s
F
Dynamic discount calculation
Sliding surface extension
End of dynamic analysis
Reduced Strength
Parameters by K
K
s
F
s
F
s
F
c
ϕ
s
F
c
ϕ
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
42
(5) According to step (2), the slope safety index is obtained after sliding surface
expansion.
(6) The dynamic and overall strength reduction method is used to repeat the above
steps to obtain a series of dynamic safety indexes, stop the reduction after the sliding
surface is penetrated, and finish dynamic security and stability evaluation of the slope.
In order to track the evolution law of the slope safety index in the whole process,
this paper, combined with the advantages of dynamic strength reduction method,
selects a representative section to study how to bring the strength reduction
calculation method into the analysis of slope dynamic safety and stability state, in
which the possibility of overall landslide occurrence is small in the gradual failure
process of the slope, but the reduction index obtained by the dynamic strength
reduction method does not represent the safety index of the slope (as in equation
(3)), only representing the degree of reduction. Therefore, the dynamic and overall
strength reduction calculation methods are combined to analyze the slope stability,
and slowly enter the unsafe state process, thereby obtaining the safety index via
calculation, and obtaining the stability state of the slope on the basis of the safety
index.
Concretely, the fractures at an overall back-edge mountain are dislocated to reduce
and a representative section is selected as the entire slope, so as to obtain the safety
index under the limit state, that is:
4
In the formula, and are the reduced cohesion force and the internal friction
angle, respectively.
4. RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
4.1. LANDSLIDE RESIDUAL MOUNTAIN CONDITIONS IN A
CERTAIN AREA
In a certain area, there is still a mountain with a vertical length of 460-500m and a
horizontal width (between the big water ditch and the small water ditch) of 460-640 m
at the rear wall of the landslide, which is characterized by a steep front edge and a
gentle back edge. The slope of the front edge (that is, the rear wall of the landslide in
a certain area) is about 45°, and the back edge is the original slope with a gentle
slope of 10° to 15°. It can be seen via qualitative analysis that the residual mountain
mass on the rear wall of a landslide in a certain area will be dominated by local
sporadic collapse and slump in the superficial part, and the possibility of overall
landslide occurrence is small. Therefore, in the quantitative calculation of stability, the
s
F
s
F
K
K
F
'
'tan
arctan
c
c
F
F
=
ϕ
ϕ=
'
c
'
ϕ
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
43
possible sliding surface is formed based on the most unfavorable residual mountain
slope structure and its various structural surfaces, which is regarded as the controlling
boundaries for quantitative calculations of stability. At the same time, the various
residual mountain slopes and superficial residual mountain slopes formed due to the
earthquake will obviously serve as the boundary of the back edge tensile fracture.
Based on comprehensive analysis, it can be inferred that the residual mountain
may have a large-scale failure mode: the back edge through fractures are dislocated
the middle layer slides
the front edge shear failure occurs, so it can also be
attributed to a three-stage mechanism of tension cracking-sliding-shearing. Among
them, the front edge of the slope crest is most likely to collapse.
4.2. EXPERIMENT PARAMETERS OF MOUNTAIN SLOPE IN A
CERTAIN AREA
According to the geological prototype, geometric mode of right bank is built, and to
perform stability calculation, a representative section is selected. Specifically, the
section model of the computational mesh model is set to be 478m long and 470m
high, and the total number of elements and nodes is 44695 and 71396 respectively.
The rock-material constitutive model adopts the Mohr Coulomb rule for the most
suitable elastic-plastic model criterion. The mechanical parameters of the three kinds
of rock dikes in the corresponding stratum distribution on the vertical surfaces on the
left and right sides, and fixed constraints on the bottom boundary are determined
respectively.
Combined with the exposed shape of the section, the slope mass is generalized as
, , , , and
rock-soil mass and concrete after support (C25
strength grade), and the mechanical parameters of the three kinds of rock dikes in the
corresponding stratum distribution are the same as IV-type rock mass. The natural
bulk density, elastic model and Poisson's ratio appearing in this experiment are all
measured by measuring instruments before the experiment. The layer parameter
values are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Parameters of the calculation model for the slope on the right side of the residual
mountain.
2V
1V
IV
2III
1III
II
Medium
Natural test
weight /
kN•m-3
Elastic Modulus
/Gpa
Poisson's
ratio Cohesion /Mpa Internal friction
angle /°
f231 25.8 2.0 0.28 0.9 22.8
Deep
unloading
fracture
26.2 2.0 0.28 2.0 36.0
V2 class 22.1 2.0 0.27 1.8 21.8
V1 class 24.5 4.0 0.27 2.0 26.5
IV class 25.8 6.0 0.26 7.0 38.6
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
44
possible sliding surface is formed based on the most unfavorable residual mountain
slope structure and its various structural surfaces, which is regarded as the controlling
boundaries for quantitative calculations of stability. At the same time, the various
residual mountain slopes and superficial residual mountain slopes formed due to the
earthquake will obviously serve as the boundary of the back edge tensile fracture.
Based on comprehensive analysis, it can be inferred that the residual mountain
may have a large-scale failure mode: the back edge through fractures are dislocated
the middle layer slides the front edge shear failure occurs, so it can also be
attributed to a three-stage mechanism of tension cracking-sliding-shearing. Among
them, the front edge of the slope crest is most likely to collapse.
4.2. EXPERIMENT PARAMETERS OF MOUNTAIN SLOPE IN A
CERTAIN AREA
According to the geological prototype, geometric mode of right bank is built, and to
perform stability calculation, a representative section is selected. Specifically, the
section model of the computational mesh model is set to be 478m long and 470m
high, and the total number of elements and nodes is 44695 and 71396 respectively.
The rock-material constitutive model adopts the Mohr Coulomb rule for the most
suitable elastic-plastic model criterion. The mechanical parameters of the three kinds
of rock dikes in the corresponding stratum distribution on the vertical surfaces on the
left and right sides, and fixed constraints on the bottom boundary are determined
respectively.
Combined with the exposed shape of the section, the slope mass is generalized as
, , , , and rock-soil mass and concrete after support (C25
strength grade), and the mechanical parameters of the three kinds of rock dikes in the
corresponding stratum distribution are the same as IV-type rock mass. The natural
bulk density, elastic model and Poisson's ratio appearing in this experiment are all
measured by measuring instruments before the experiment. The layer parameter
values are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Parameters of the calculation model for the slope on the right side of the residual
mountain.
2V
1V
IV
2III
1III
II
Medium
Natural test
weight /
kN•m-3
Elastic Modulus
/Gpa
Poisson's
ratio
Cohesion /Mpa
Internal friction
angle /°
f231
25.8
2.0
0.28
0.9
22.8
Deep
unloading
fracture
26.2
2.0
0.28
2.0
36.0
V2 class
22.1
2.0
0.27
1.8
21.8
V1 class
24.5
4.0
0.27
2.0
26.5
IV class
25.8
6.0
0.26
7.0
38.6
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
In Table 1, a total of 87 groups of physical and mechanical tests of rock blocks have
been completed on the residual mountain. The values of mechanical parameters are
comprehensively determined on the basis of indoor and outdoor tests, combined with
engineering analogy and parameter inversion.
For a homogeneous slope in mountains at a certain area, its geometric model is
shown in Figure 4, and its material property parameters are shown in Table 2.
Figure 4. Geometric model of the homogeneous slope of the mountain
Table 2. Soil parameters of mountain homogeneous slope
Midas GTS NX is a kind of software that can analyze soil layers and tunnel
structures, which can carry out various analysis of related mountains, strata, soil
layers and tunnels, such as the mechanical parameter analysis of the three kinds of
rock dikes in the corresponding stratum distribution, as well as solid structure and type
analysis, with fast analysis speed, excellent graphics and output capabilities.
Therefore, in this study, Midas GTS NX software is adopted to analyze the stability of
three kinds of residual mountain slopes using the finite element limit equilibrium
method, Bishop method, Janbu method and the mountain slope calculation model
designed herein based on the strength reduction method in order.
The geometric model and material property parameters of a multi-layer soil slope
on a mountain in a certain area are shown in Figure 5, and Table 3 respectively.
III1 class 26.2 8.0 0.24 15.0 50.2
III2 class 26.2 7.5 0.23 17.5 51.3
III class 26.5 9.0 0.22 20.0 52.5
45m
20m
100m 200m 190m
c/kPa φ/(°) γ/kN/m3E/Mpa υ
3 19.6 20 10 0.25
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
45
Figure 5. Geometric model of a multi-layer soil slope in mountain
Table 3. Soil parameters of a multi-layer soil slope in mountain
The geometric model and material property parameters of a soft interlining slope in
a certain area are shown in Figure 6, and Table 4 respectively.
Figure 6. Geometric model of a weak interlining slope in mountain
Table 4. Soil parameters of a weak interlining slope in mountain
Soil layer3
Soil layer2
Soil layer1
45m
25m
50m 128m 130m
Soil
layer c/kPa φ/(°) γ/kN/m3E/Mpa υ
1 0 38.0 19.5 10 0.25
2 5.3 23.0 19.5 10 0.25
3 7.2 20.0 19.5 10 0.25
Soil
layer c/kPa φ/(°) γ/kN/m3E/Mpa υ
1 28.5 20.0 18.84 60 0.25
2 0 10.0 18.84 20 0.25
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
46
Figure 5. Geometric model of a multi-layer soil slope in mountain
Table 3. Soil parameters of a multi-layer soil slope in mountain
The geometric model and material property parameters of a soft interlining slope in
a certain area are shown in Figure 6, and Table 4 respectively.
Figure 6. Geometric model of a weak interlining slope in mountain
Table 4. Soil parameters of a weak interlining slope in mountain
Soil layer3
Soil layer2
Soil layer1
45m
25m
50m 128m 130m
Soil
layer
c/kPa
φ/(°)
γ/kN/m3
E/Mpa
υ
1
0
38.0
19.5
10
0.25
2
5.3
23.0
19.5
10
0.25
3
7.2
20.0
19.5
10
0.25
Soil
layer
c/kPa
φ/(°)
γ/kN/m3
E/Mpa
υ
1
28.5
20.0
18.84
60
0.25
2
0
10.0
18.84
20
0.25
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
4.3. COMPARE WITH THE RESULTS OF DIFFERENT
ALGORITHMS
The calculation results of slope stability are shown in Figure 7 in detail.
After the stability of a homogeneous slope in a certain area is calculated by the
finite element limit equilibrium method, the Bishop method, the Janbu method and the
mountain slope calculation model designed in this paper according to the mechanical
parameters of the three kinds of rock dikes in the corresponding stratum distribution, it
is obvious from Figure 7 (a) that, in a certain area, the maximum safety index
calculated via mountain slope calculation model designed in this paper is 1.081, while
the maximum safety index calculated by the finite element limit equilibrium method is
1.013, the maximum safety index calculated by the Bishop method is 0.993, and the
maximum safety index calculated by the Janbu method is 0.978, indicating that the
slope stability safety index of a homogeneous slope in a certain area calculated by
mountain slope calculation model is increased by 6.7%, 8.8% and 10.5% compared
with that calculated by finite element limit equilibrium method, Bishop method and
Janbu method respectively.
Similarly, in the stability analysis of a multi-layer soil slope, the maximum safety
index calculated by mountain slope calculation model designed in this paper is 1.450,
while the maximum safety index calculated by the finite element limit equilibrium
method, Bishop method and Janbu method is 1.390, 1.383, and 1.325 successively,
indicating that the slope stability safety index of a multi-layer soil slope calculated by
strength reduction method is 6.7%, 8.8% and 10.5%. higher than that calculated by
finite element limit equilibrium method, Bishop method and Janbu method. The
concrete results is as shown in Figure 7(b)
Again, as can be seen from Figure 7(c), in the stability analysis of a weak interlining
slope, the safety index calculated by the finite element limit equilibrium method is
1.027, the safety index calculated by the the Bishop method is 1.003., and the safety
index calculated by the Janbu method is 1.024. Compared with other three algorithms,
the safety index of slope stability calculated by strength reduction method is increased
by 26.46%,, 29.11% and 26.10% respectively.
Strength reduction
method
Finite Element Limit
Equilibrium Method
Bishop method Janbu method
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
Safety factor
Calculation method
Safety factor
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
47
(a) Calculation results of the stability of the homogeneous slope of the mountain
(b) Calculation results of the stability of the multi-layer soil slope in the mountain
(c) Calculation results of stability of mountain slope with weak interlayer
Figure 7. The results of the mountain stability experiment
All the above data suggests that based on strength reduction method, the mountain
slope calculation model designed in this paper has an optimal stability analysis effect
for the three kinds of slope types in mountains, and the weak interlining slopes in
mountain have the best stability.
5. DISCUSSION
Through the research of this paper, the author thinks that it is necessary to further
bring the strength reduction method into the actual use of reinforced concrete in the
calculation of the stability safety index of mountain slopes, and maybe the seepage
field can be simulated by the function of simulating the temperature field. Also, the
author reckons that there are still several deficiencies in the case analysis of this
paper. For instance, the influence of groundwater has not been considered and the
Strength reduction
method
Finite Element Limit
Equilibrium Method
Bishop method Janbu method
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
Safety factor
Calculation method
Safety factor
Strength reduction
method
Finite Element Limit
Equilibrium Method
Bishop method Janbu method
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
Safety factor
Calculation method
Safety factor
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
48
(a) Calculation results of the stability of the homogeneous slope of the mountain
(b) Calculation results of the stability of the multi-layer soil slope in the mountain
(c) Calculation results of stability of mountain slope with weak interlayer
Figure 7. The results of the mountain stability experiment
All the above data suggests that based on strength reduction method, the mountain
slope calculation model designed in this paper has an optimal stability analysis effect
for the three kinds of slope types in mountains, and the weak interlining slopes in
mountain have the best stability.
5. DISCUSSION
Through the research of this paper, the author thinks that it is necessary to further
bring the strength reduction method into the actual use of reinforced concrete in the
calculation of the stability safety index of mountain slopes, and maybe the seepage
field can be simulated by the function of simulating the temperature field. Also, the
author reckons that there are still several deficiencies in the case analysis of this
paper. For instance, the influence of groundwater has not been considered and the
Strength reduction
method
Finite Element Limit
Equilibrium Method
Bishop method Janbu method
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
Safety factor
Calculation method
Safety factor
Strength reduction
method
Finite Element Limit
Equilibrium Method
Bishop method Janbu method
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
Safety factor
Calculation method
Safety factor
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
application of the various residual mountain slopes in the rock slopes is not studied,
where only the shear damage of rock and soil structure is analyzed. In this regard,
future research may create a subject aiming at the influence of groundwater on slope
stability, and focus on the practical application of strength reduction calculation
method in rock slopes on the basis of the tensile failure of rock and soil, the practical
application of strength reduction calculation method in the safe and stable state
analysis of foundations and underground caverns, and other practical applications
from all walks of life. Moreover. how to use the strength reduction method to design
the support structure in the foundation, cavern and slope is a also topic worthy of
further study.
6. CONCLUSION
China is a mountainous country, where geological disasters such as landslides
occur frequently every year, and losses caused thereupon are vitally massive. When
carrying out landslide disaster management, it is the top priority of current mountain
stability research to reasonably introduce relevant algorithms into the research on the
stability of combined residual mountain slopes. Therefore, this paper proposes a
strength reduction calculation model in the study of the stability of the residual
mountains. And the following conclusions are drawn from the study:
1. The deformation and failure characteristics of the residual slope on the rear wall of
a landslide in a certain area is analyzed. To be precise, from the distribution of three
groups of fractures with different extension directions and scales formed on the
surface of the residual mountain in a certain area, the vibration unloading effect is
not only in the direction of the mouth of the river, but also in the direction of the big
water ditch and the small water ditch. Collapse, sliding and cracking also occur, but
the former has more advantages. Moreover, although the shallow surface layer of
the residual mountain slope in a certain area is disturbed by the earthquake, the
integrity of the underlying weakly weathered rock mass remains basically intact.
2. The stability of a multi-layer soil slope in a certain area in residual mountains via the
method proposed in this paper, finite element limit equilibrium method, Bishop
method and Janbu method is analyzed. It is found that the safety index obtained by
the method proposed in this paper is 6.7%, 8.8%, and 10.5% higher than that
calculated byother three methods in order.
3. The stability of a homogeneous slope in a certain area in residual mountains via the
method proposed in this paper, finite element limit equilibrium method, Bishop
method and Janbu method is analyzed. It is obvious that compared with other three
methods, the safety index obtained by the method in this paper is increase by 4.8%,
4.3%, and 9.4% respectively. Similarly, in a weak interlining slope the safety index
obtained by this method is 26.10%, 29.11%, and 26.46% higher than the other
three methods successively, indicating that the stability of the landslide residual
mountain calculated by the strength reduction method in this paper is the highest.
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
49
7. DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT
The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/
supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.
REFERENCES
(1) Wei W B, Cheng Y M. (2019). Stability analysis of slope with water flow by
strength reduction method[j]. Soils & Foundations, 50(1), 83-92.
(2) Chen J F, Liu J X, Xue J F. (2017). Stability analyses of a reinforced soil wall
on soft soils using strength reduction method[J]. Engineering Geology.
(3) Wang L Y, Chen W Z, Tan X Y. (2019). Evaluation of mountain slope stability
considering the impact of geological interfaces using discrete fractures
model[J]. Journal of Mountain Science, 16(9), 2184-2202.
(4) Wang Y, Jiang W, Li B. (2021).
Deformation Monitoring and Evaluation of
Mountain Slope Stability Combined With Ground-based Radar and
Spaceborne InSAR Methods.
(5) Xin Z, Han J, Zhuoyang L I. (2020).
Viability of high-density resistivity
method for evaluating mountain slope stability in Erdaojiang District,
Tonghua City, China[J]. World Geology: English Edition.
(6) Pingkang Wang, Youhai Zhu, Zhenquan Lu, Xia Huang, Shouji Pang and Shuai
Zhang. (2017).
Gas hydrate stability zone migration occurred in the Qilian
mountain permafrost, Qinghai, Northwest China: Evidences from pyrite
morphology and pyrite sulfur isotope[J].
Cold Regions Science and
Technology.
(7) Wang L Y, Chen W Z, Tan X Y. (2019). Evaluation of mountain slope stability
considering the impact of geological interfaces using discrete fractures
model[J]. Journal of Mountain Science: English Edition, 16(9), 19.
(8) Xue F, Wang X. (2018). Study on stability of the Santai Mountain landslide
based on FLAC~(3D) numerical simulation[C]. 2018 International Conference
on Computational Science and Engineering.
(9) Liu W. (2018). Study on foundation stability of a mountain project in Tianjin
Binhai district[J]. IOP Conference Series Materials Science and Engineering,
452(3), 032060.
(10) Jian H, Zuo D, Xiao J. (2018).
Fast Evaluation and Application Study for
Road Slope Stability in Mountain Area Based on Android Platform[J].
Safety and Environmental Engineering.
(11) Wang H. (2017).
Study on stability of high and steep slope in mountain
reservoir[J]. Building Structure.
(12) Dong T W, Zheng Y R, Huang L Z. (2018). Study of Ultimately Loading of Pile
Foundation by Strength Reduction Method of No-Linear Limit Analysis of
FEM[J]. Advanced Materials Research, 168-170, 2537-2542.
(13) Simatupang P T, Ohtsuka S. (2018).
Static and Seismic Slope Stability
Analyses Based on Strength Reduction Method[J].
Doboku Gakkai
Ronbunshuu A, 3, 235-246.
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
50
7. DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT
The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/
supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.
REFERENCES
(1) Wei W B, Cheng Y M. (2019). Stability analysis of slope with water flow by
strength reduction method[j]. Soils & Foundations, 50(1), 83-92.
(2) Chen J F, Liu J X, Xue J F. (2017). Stability analyses of a reinforced soil wall
on soft soils using strength reduction method[J]. Engineering Geology.
(3) Wang L Y, Chen W Z, Tan X Y. (2019). Evaluation of mountain slope stability
considering the impact of geological interfaces using discrete fractures
model[J]. Journal of Mountain Science, 16(9), 2184-2202.
(4) Wang Y, Jiang W, Li B. (2021). Deformation Monitoring and Evaluation of
Mountain Slope Stability Combined With Ground-based Radar and
Spaceborne InSAR Methods.
(5) Xin Z, Han J, Zhuoyang L I. (2020). Viability of high-density resistivity
method for evaluating mountain slope stability in Erdaojiang District,
Tonghua City, China[J]. World Geology: English Edition.
(6) Pingkang Wang, Youhai Zhu, Zhenquan Lu, Xia Huang, Shouji Pang and Shuai
Zhang. (2017). Gas hydrate stability zone migration occurred in the Qilian
mountain permafrost, Qinghai, Northwest China: Evidences from pyrite
morphology and pyrite sulfur isotope[J]. Cold Regions Science and
Technology.
(7) Wang L Y, Chen W Z, Tan X Y. (2019). Evaluation of mountain slope stability
considering the impact of geological interfaces using discrete fractures
model[J]. Journal of Mountain Science: English Edition, 16(9), 19.
(8) Xue F, Wang X. (2018). Study on stability of the Santai Mountain landslide
based on FLAC~(3D) numerical simulation[C]. 2018 International Conference
on Computational Science and Engineering.
(9) Liu W. (2018). Study on foundation stability of a mountain project in Tianjin
Binhai district[J]. IOP Conference Series Materials Science and Engineering,
452(3), 032060.
(10) Jian H, Zuo D, Xiao J. (2018). Fast Evaluation and Application Study for
Road Slope Stability in Mountain Area Based on Android Platform[J].
Safety and Environmental Engineering.
(11) Wang H. (2017). Study on stability of high and steep slope in mountain
reservoir[J]. Building Structure.
(12) Dong T W, Zheng Y R, Huang L Z. (2018). Study of Ultimately Loading of Pile
Foundation by Strength Reduction Method of No-Linear Limit Analysis of
FEM[J]. Advanced Materials Research, 168-170, 2537-2542.
(13) Simatupang P T, Ohtsuka S. (2018). Static and Seismic Slope Stability
Analyses Based on Strength Reduction Method[J]. Doboku Gakkai
Ronbunshuu A, 3, 235-246.
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
(14) Chen L, Jin X. (2019).
Study on the applicability of three criteria for slope
instability using finite element strength reduction method[J].
China Civil
Engineering Journal, 45(9), 136-146.
(15) Ying K, Chen P, Yu H.
Analysis of Rock High-Slope Stability Based on a
Particle Flow Code Strength Reduction Method[J].
Electronic Journal of
Geotechnical Engineering, 20(28), 13421-13430.
(16) Abbas F, Zhu Z, An S. (2021).
Evaluating aggregate stability of soils under
different plant species in Ziwuling Mountain area using three renowned
methods[J]. Catena, 207(15), 105616.
(17) Wang S, Li X C, Shi L. (2017).
Material point strength reduction method and
its application to slope engineering[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics.
(18) Chen G Q, Huang R Q, Zhou H. (2017).
Research on progressive failure for
slope using dynamic strength reduction method[J].
Yantu Lixue/Rock and
Soil Mechanics.
(19) Sheng-Dong X U, Zhang X, Zhang J. (2017).
Stability analysis of multi-step
slope based on strength reduction method[j].
Journal of Geological Hazards
and Environment Preservation.
(20) Schneider-Muntau, Barbara, Medicus. (2018).
Strength reduction method in
Barodesy[J]. Computers & Geotechnics.
(21) Sun Y, Duan X R, Xu P H. (2021).
Reliability analysis of karst roof stability
based on strength reduction method[J].
IOP Conference Series: Earth and
Environmental Science, 861(7), 072118(8).
(22) Yunjin H U, Zhong Z, Gao H. (2021).
Three-parameter strength reduction
method for slope stability evaluation.
(23) Zhang Zhewen, Gao Huaxi. (2019).
Effect of repressive layer on stability of
seawall based on strength reduction method[J].
Water Transport
Engineering, 000(006), 180-185.
(24) Shan, Shan, LU. (2018).
Dynamic Stability Analysis of Arch Dam Abutment
Based on Strength Reduction Method[C].
(25) Ying K, Chen P, Yu H. (2018).
Analysis of Rock High-Slope Stability Based
on a Particle Flow Code Strength Reduction Method[J].
Electronic Journal of
Geotechnical Engineering, 20(28), 13421-13430.
(26) Tulu I B, Esterhuizen G S, Klemetti T. (2016).
A case study of multi-seam coal
mine entry stability analysis with strength reduction method[J]
.
International Journal of Mining Science and Technology.
(27) Bai B, Yuan W, Shi L. (2017).
Comparing a new double reduction method to
classic strength reduction method for slope stability analysis[J].
Rock and
Soil Mechanics, 36(5), 1275-1281.
(28) Y Zhou, T Chen, J Deng. (2019).
Three-dimensional stability analysis of
slope regions based on strength reduction method.
(29) Yang Y, Wang Y, Wu Y. (2017).
The effect of variable modulus elastoplastic
strength reduction method on slope stability[J].
Electronic Journal of
Geotechnical Engineering, 20(1), 1-10.
(30) Tu Y, Liu X, Zhong Z (2018).
New criteria for defining slope failure using the
strength reduction method[J]. Engineering Geology, 212, 63-71.
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
51
(31) Schneider-Muntau B, Medicus G, Fellin W. (2017). Strength reduction method
in Barodesy[J]. Computers and Geotechnics, 95, 57-67.
(32) Tulu I B, Esterhuizen G S, Klemetti T. (2018). A case study of multi-seam coal
mine entry stability analysis with strength reduction method[J].
International Journal of Mining Science and Technology.
(33) Nie Z B, Zheng H, Zhang T. (2017).
Determination of slope critical slip
surfaces using strength reduction method and wavelet transform[J]. Rock
and Soil Mechanics.
(34) Hou W, University L. (2018). Stability Analysis of Inhomogeneous and Multi-
step Slope Based on Strength Reduction Method[J]. Subgrade Engineering.
(35) Wei Y, Xiao-Tian H, Xiao-Chun L I. (2017).
A strength reduction method
considering reduction of strength parameters coordinating with
deformation parameters[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics.
(36) Yan C, Liu S Y, Xiao-Lei J I. (2018). Research on a secondary sliding surface
analysis approach based on strength reduction method[J].
Rock and Soil
Mechanics.
(37) Maqache, N., y Swart, A., J. (2021).
Remotely measuring and controlling
specific parameters of a PV module via an RF link. 3C Tecnología. Glosas de
innovación aplicadas a la pyme, 10(4), 103-129. https://doi.org/
10.17993/3ctecno/2021.v10n4e40.103-129
(38) Shen Siqi. (2021).
Multi-attribute decision-making methods based on
normal random variables in supply chain risk management. Applied
Mathematics and Nonlinear Sciences, 7(1), 719-728. https://doi.org/10.2478/
AMNS.2021.2.00147.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any
commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of
interest.
https://doi.org/10.17993/3ctecno.2023.v12n1e43.33-52
3C Tecnología. Glosas de innovación aplicadas a la pyme. ISSN: 2254-4143
Ed.43 | Iss.12 | N.1 January - March 2023
52